“Balancing” or Censorship?

It has not taken long for PM David Cameron’s likening of Gaza to a prison camp to draw ire:

Foreign Office sources suggested Downing Street had been remiss in omitting from Cameron’s speech the sort of “balancing” comments that are routinely made about Israel’s security – especially the fate of a captured soldier being held by Hamas – when its policies on the Palestinians are criticised. [Source]

While presenting my paper at last week’s conference I touched upon the subject of art and censorship vis-a-vis Palestine.

When, in 2006, the Israeli student Lior Halperin established an exhibition of child art from Palestinian refugee camps at Brandeis University, the exhibit was removed after a mere four days.

The reasoning behind the removal was cited as ‘balance’ – the university could not exhibit a Palestinian show without an accompanying Israeli exhibition.

That there was no Israeli exhibition resulted in the display being removed and the issue wiped from the agenda.

As I related the account various members of the audience nodded slowly or chuckled in anticipation –  for they understood the  subtext.

Likewise, the condemnation for what Cameron ostensibly addressed as the truth is merely post-quip censorship.

That Cameron did not mention the captive soldier, Gilad Shalit, in his speech does not lessen the gravity of Shalit’s circumstances as Ron Prosor, Israel’s ambassador to Britain, denotes:

The people of Gaza are the prisoners of the terrorist organisation Hamas. The situation in Gaza is the direct result of Hamas’s rule and priorities.

We know that the prime minister would also share our grave concerns about our own prisoner in the Gaza Strip, Gilad Shalit, who has been held hostage there for over four years, without receiving a single Red Cross visit. [Source]

Rather, it is rare occasion when the plight of Gaza is mentioned by a British leader – that it should be ‘balanced’ is irrelevent.

It is a situation that must not be detracted from and strong terminology must be used in cases such as this.

Gaza cannot be neutralized nor ignored – indeed, ‘prison camp’ is even an understatement in describing the conditions.

‘Hell’ would be a greater approximation, and yes, both Hamas and Israel are to blame at varying degrees.

Cameron On Gaza

As much as it pains me to break with tradition and agree with a Tory, David Cameron is (ahem) right on the mark:

The situation in Gaza has to change. Humanitarian goods and people must flow in both directions. Gaza cannot and must not be allowed to remain a prison camp.

The Israeli attack on the Gaza flotilla was completely unacceptable and I have told PM Netanyahu we will expect the Israeli inquiry to be swift, transparent and rigorous. [Source]

Let’s hope he has more cojones than his predecessors in moving beyond statement and into action.

Israel’s (Potential) Anti-Rights Legislation

Although this deserves so much more than a brief snippet and a link, my flight from Barcelona beckons and I must type against the clock.

In essence, therefore:

Four bills and amendments are pending that would seriously restrict the rights of Israelis to criticize the policies and actions of their government, Human Rights Watch said.

One would shut down groups that communicate information that could be used in charges filed in other countries against members of the Israeli government or army for violations of international law. A second would penalize organizations and individuals who express support for, or participate in, boycotts against Israel. A third would impose onerous and immediate reporting requirements on any group that accepts any amount of funding from a foreign government for any purpose, and the fourth would punish anyone who assists refugees after they illegally cross into Israel.

Of course, this raises the whole spectre of Israel’s relationship with democracy: it is more on and off than a celebrity dalliance.

Before pouring forth condemnation, it must first be approved – or disapproved – and we can only hope some degree of sense will prevail and make the choice the latter.

Find out more at Human Rights Watch, here.

Pomegranates and Myrrh

Running parallel to the conference through the week has been an Arabic film festival, comprising works from Lebanon, Palestine, Iraq and North Africa.

Admittedly most frequently drawn into its dark depths by the promise of the most powerful air-conditioning on campus, some of the movies have been compelling (Maid for Sale), tedious (Basra) or oddly fascinating (Help).

By far the best however, is Pomegranates and Myrrh (Al Mor wa al Rumman), a 2009 Ramallah-based film by Najwa Najjar.

While the official blurb provides an idea of the film’s premise, it utterly fails to do it justice:

Ramallah, this decade. A free spirited woman dancer, Kamar, finds herself the wife of a prisoner, Zaid, and away from everything she loves until she returns to the dance, defying society’s taboos. At the dance, Kamar is confronted with Kais, a Palestinian returnee, who has taken Kamar’s role as the head choreographer. Sparks fly between Kamar and Kais, creating a more than passionate, emotional dance for both of them. Matters become even more complicated when Zaid’s sentence is extended.

To read the above would be to believe that it is a love story between two people (Kamar and Kais), with dance providing the backdrop.

This could not be further from the point, for central to Najjar’s piece is the land – indeed, a love-affair with the land, rather than Kais.

For Zaid, the land is worth more than his family, his wife or even his freedom: when Kamar tearfully pleads with him to sign the document that would allow the confiscation of the olive groves to proceed, but guarantee his freedom, he responds: ‘If the land is gone, then all is lost.’

Kamar’s relationship to the land is intrinsically linked to her own emotions: after the final argument with Zaid in jail, she ploughs the land visciously by hand.

Likewise, she dances her frustrations out on the bare soil of the night orchard, kicking up the dust and stones in feverish whirls.

The men, rather, assume a nominal role in the story.

During the Q&A session Najwa stressed the role of women not only in the movie, but in the making of it, with a number of significant positions being enacted by women.

Moreover, it is the mothers who support and guide Kamar, her sister who prompts her to return to dance and the formidable Umm Habib who provides a ballsy scene of rebuke to the IDF soldiers that raises a thousand goosebumps.

Surprisingly, in addition to these wonderfully profound themes Najjar brings the intifada to our midst in the most powerful manner.

The confiscation scene, the threat of the settlers, the futility of their Israeli lawyer and the endless injustice that is administrative detention is heart-breaking.

Pomegranates and Myrrh is quite possibly the best Palestinian movie in years – which makes it all the more irksome that the only copy on Amazon is a Swedish version.

But, should the lucky opportunity arise, do not miss what will be a truly moving and astounding piece of Middle Eastern contemporary cinema.

O, Canada

You disappoint me so.

For years I have been under the impression that you were of the gentle, rational persuasion.

Which is why the following quips come as such an unwelcome surprise:

Canada recognizes Israel’s legitimate security concerns and its right to protect its citizens from terrorist attacks, including through the restriction of access to its territory, and its right to inspect ships in order to ensure that weapons and other military equipment do not reach the Gaza Strip.

[However] while we fully support the importance of delivering humanitarian aid to the people of Gaza, we also fully support Israel’s right to inspect ships to ensure military material and armaments do not reach the hands of Hamas terrorists. [Source]

There is a degree of veracity in the above: security must be maintained.

Nevertheless, it is almost as though the deaths of the civilians onboard never occurred – there is mention of inspection, but where is the line drawn between the purveyance of a craft and the murder of its inhabitants?

The political dogmatism sits in strong contrast to that of European Ministers, for whom the blockade is “unacceptable and counter-productive,” while the past week the US has bandied about the word ‘untenable’ in conjunction with the blockade.

Of course, Canada knows that inspection is one thing and overt violence resulting in death is another.

Which makes their unstinting support of the blockade all the more distasteful.

If You Do One Good Thing Today…

… Let it be this.

The following is a first on this site, and a rather lovely one: a call for donations towards an immensely worthy organization via a rather remarkable woman:

My name is Zainab Balousha and I am one of the students who received a scholarship from the Durham Palestine Educational Trust this year. I am studying for the MSc in Design and Operations Engineering , learning skills that are in short supply in Palestine. Because I know the tremendous value of these scholarships to Palestine and to Palestinians, I want to help the Trust to finance next year’s scholarships.



So, I am taking part in the Trust’s Sponsored Walk over a 12-mile route on Sunday 27 June. I have never done a sponsored walk before but I hope to survive it. I’m trying to raise £500 for the Trust and make a real contribution to its fantastic efforts on behalf of Palestinians over the last 26 years. I would be very, very grateful if you could help by sponsoring my efforts.

I first encountered Zainab as a tutee and her delightful charisma ensured that while in different departments, she is utterly unforgettable.

I might add even more so due to her relentless dedication to raising awareness and in this instance, donations towards Palestinian causes.

A few months past I posted on a Palestine event held by our college and it was at this event that Zainab succeeded in bringing the tragedy, urgency and awe of the Gazan people to a bucolic corner of Britain.

Although my friends had been wooed into attending with the promise of falafel and humus, the food was soon forgotten when Zainab took to the microphone: my friends wept at her strength and endurance: she is brilliant, shining example of what is possible if the opportunities are presented.

Which is why, if you must do one good thing today, pop over to Zainab’s page and drop a few coins in the cyber-box.

The process will take but seconds, but the act will change a young Palestinian’s life, forever.

The Power of Film

This week has been achingly busy in all manner of ways, not in the least with the culmination of the conference at which I touted my latest academic creation.

The weekend then, was something to look forward to; regrettably, though for the first time in days the rain has held off, it is still (in a non-meteo fashion) promising to be a damp squib.

And so I found myself in the city buying a bunch of DVDs – for nothing shuts out the world quite like a good book, or in a pinch, movie.

Admittedly, my choices were not exactly of the mood-tickling variety: Death in Gaza and Waltz with Bashir.

Nevertheless, it was the cashier’s response that proved the lifting part.

A young Englishman with a shaven head and delightful North East accent, he exclaimed in recognition when scanning the latter.

“Have you seen this film? Amazing. I felt like I had been kicked about after watching it. What these people go through is tragic, so terrible, and yet we know nothing about it. All this happened and where were we?”

[Picks up Death in Gaza]

“And this. I was in tears. It really makes you wonder why we don’t get involved. Those poor children, growing up in that environment – why don’t we say to Israel, ‘Oi, look mate, this is wrong – stop’? We just sit here. Doing nothing. Do you know about it?”

I nodded assent and said I work on this. Have known about it for years.

“Wow. And yet you can still smile. How can you know about this and still be happy every day? I felt so down. I really want to do something, but don’t know what. Here I am just recommending DVDs [he had recommended Death in Gaza] when they need real help.”

I thought about it, then told him he was helping.

The media does not cover the issues in Gaza and Lebanon extensively and the result is, as he said, that many British youth (and even older) do not know of the human rights abuses occurring in the region.

That he learned of the events through film is indicative of the power exerted by the medium, a power to educate and enhance awareness.

And so, I told him that his recommendation was a small step, but a step nonetheless towards helping.

The more people know, the greater the awareness.

The greater the awareness, the larger the capacity for change.

And so, from tiny seeds can large trees grow.

This Is Empowerment: Haneen Zoubi

Over rice crispies this morning I had a discussion with my flatmate about contemporary representations of female empowerment.

To look at the most recent example in the media, Sex and the City 2, the message is clear: it is about clothes, sex, money and BFFs.

However, I am fairly certain that if I spy one more magazine boasting ‘Top Power Females’ to be followed by images of smirking celebrities, I will squeal and sprout a beard.

My dear womankind, this is empowerment:

I want to see women like Zoabi gracing the covers of magazines; I want my children to grow up understanding that female empowerment is about determination, integrity and the belief in justice.

And that it is the ability to expound these beliefs with more cojones than a room full of men that matters most.

Haneen Zoubi is fast becoming an icon.

And quite rightly.

Kudos to… Tanya Nagar

It’s been a while since the last kudos-based post, but I am delighted to have stumbled across this one.

How I did not before is nigh unbelievable, for Tanya Nagar‘s images all but bestowed repetitive strain injury from striking the ‘add to faves’ star on Flickr.

And here’s a sample of why:

Of particular envy is her inherent ability to capture street scenes, without, I imagine, being chased.

I still covet that skill.

To see more of Tanya’s amazing work, click here.

[And on a brief tangent, I cannot recommend this post by Roba enough: it has cured by writer's block no end.]

Israel Launches ‘Free Cyprus’ Flotilla

You couldn’t make it up:

In response to Turkey’s lead role in sponsoring the hostile ‘Free Gaza’ flotilla this week, a former Knesset member and a Left-wing activist are joining a group of Israeli boaters as part of a flotilla leaving next week for Cyprus to highlight and call for an end to the Turkish occupation of half the island and the reunification of the country under Cypriot rule.

Another flotilla was heading out to the seas off Tel Aviv to salute the heroic performance of the Israeli navy in intercepting the Gaza convoy. [Source]

The words ‘hypocrisy,’ ‘irony,’ and ‘craptastically bonkers’ spring to mind so fast I almost fell off my chair reading the headline.